Harry Potter & Hermione on St-Paul and the defeat of death

(Yes, this is indeed a post about Harry Potter and Hermione discussing a bible verse!)

***warning: there could be spoilers following here about the end of ‘Harry Potter and the deathly hallows’. ***

I’ve been thinking lately about one of the 2 bible verses used in Harry Potter and the deathly hallows. Both of them are used on gravestones in Godrics Hollow, Harry and Hermione are running for Voldemorts death eaters and looking for a clue in  the village where both his parents and the family of Dumbledore have lived.

Those well versed in the bible will recognise the words on the grave of Harry’s parents as those of St-Paul in I Corinthians 15:26.

(the other bible verse is from Jesus in Matthew 6:21: ‘where your treasure is, there your heart will be also’ on the grave of dumbledore’s family)

So let’s go to the Harry Potter scene:

Harry read the words slowly, as though he would have only one chance to take in their meaning, and he read the last of them out aloud.
The last enemy that shall be destroyed is death.” A horrible thought came to him, and with it a kind of panic.’Isn’ that a death eater idea? Why is that here?’
‘It doesn’t mean defeating death the way the death eaters mean it, Harry.’ said Hermione, het vioce gentle. ‘It means… you know, living beyond death, living after death.’ (HP&TDH, 268-269)

what’s so interesting here? The first thing Harry thinks of when reading these words is the philosophies of Voldemorts death eaters. It’s true thatVoldemort surely wants to destroy death. He uses all kinds of black magic, in which he himself even kills and destroys other people, to make sure that he’s not going to die, and it is clear that he does this because he is scared of death. (Something we see in our culture as well…) Trying to conquer death by all means possible, because we’re scared of it. Trying to master death, but it won’t work. It didn’t work with Voldemort and his black magic, and it doesn’t work at all with our science and technology either, whatever we try. Death is an inevitable part of life in this world, that we can not just ignore… Nor magic nor science and technology (two things closer to each other than we’d suspect, but that’s another subject) will help us to ‘destroy’ death in this way, and if they would, we’d be off much worse.

Hermione is more sensible. Why in the world would anyone write a slogan of dark wizzards on the grave of Harry’s parents anyway? ‘It’s about living beyong death, living after death.’ Now those are clearly 2 different things. Living after death is not only something that’s somewhere in the background assumed by Rowling in the Harry Potter books, but foremost something we as Christians do believe in. even though I’m not too sure about the ways some people talk about ‘heaven’, which are not at all compatible with the biblical idea of the resurrection of the death at the judgement and the new heaven and the new earth. But then we are talking about after this world, or at least after the renewal of this world.

But let’s go further with the first idea, and the r-word. Living beyond death, or resurrection. Even in the Harry Potter book we see such a thing, when Voldemort tries to kill Harry, which does not work, Harry does in some kind of way come back from the death he had accepted. The death he is willing to die to save his friends and the whole society of wizzards.

But here we see the paradox of Christus Victor. The grain of wheat has to die before the plant can grow and bear fruit. Jesus had to die, to give Himself up completely, to be able to resurrect in a new resurrection body and defeat the powers of evil. We even see this in all the Harry Potter books: Harry’s mothers sacrifice protects him against Voldemort. The one who wants to conquer death by killing even more, bringing even more death, the one who does not understand love, sacrifice and anything meaningful, which will be his end.

Our human ways of trying to not have to deal with death are in the end even more destructive. The way of Jesus is different: giving our lives, sacrificing ourselves, so death loses its power and we share in the life of the resurrection.

We are called to take up our own cross and follow Him. We are called to die to ourselves. The so-called prayer of St-Francis (which is most probably not from Francis of Assisi) says it like this:

For it is in giving that we receive,
it is in pardoning that we are pardoned,
and it is in dying that we are born to eternal life.

so what do you all think about death as the last enemy to be destroyed?





5 responses to “Harry Potter & Hermione on St-Paul and the defeat of death

  1. Pingback: Tweets that mention Harry Potter & Hermione on St-Paul and the defeat of death | Brambonius' blog in english -- Topsy.com

  2. I think it’s something men worry about more t han women. Women have always traditionally dealt with death, with preparing the body for burial and weeping at the grave. They are less avoidant of it and seem to accept it more. Men are more inclined to view themselves as immortal and fear the death of their ego, which is more separate and therefore more fragile. I think a theology constructed around a fear of death is a highly masculine one.

  3. Pingback: When death dies, all things live | Brambonius' blog in english

  4. We moeten niet sterven aan onszelf. De dood wordt in ons overwonnen als we het leven van God toelaten. Dat voelt als sterven. Onze ziel is in handen van satan en onderworpen aan de wet, die de dood tot gevolg heeft (door de zonde) maar als onze geest uit de gevangenis komt (opstaat uit de dood= wederom geboren wordt) wordt onze ziel vanuit onze geest tot leven gewekt (satan moet wijken en wij krijgen het gevoel alsof we sterven) en als de ziel het Leven heeft geabsorbeerd, werkt het door naar het lichaam en zullen wij uiteindelijk de dood overwinnen in ons lichaam (ziekte, dood en sterfelijkheid verdwijnen). Dood waar is je prikkel. De mens leeft dan vanuit zijn levende geest en bestuurt ziel en lichaam. Dat wij moeten sterven aan onszelf is een grote leugen. Jezus wekt ons op uit de dood. De graankorrel sterft (Jezus) voor ons. Het is allemaal al volbracht, opdat wij leven met Hem. Alles wat ons rest is Zijn leven toelaten in onze geest, ziel en lichaam. Alle eer aan Hem, die LEVEN en LIEFDE is.

  5. Pingback: The power found in the True Language of the Universe… | Brambonius' blog in english

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.